Knowledge CentrePolicy BriefsResearchAcademic CentreThink PiecesNewsJoinAboutContact
About
NewsJoinAboutSubscribeContact

Think Piece

Is political apathy threatening democracy? - Christopher Pich

Published:
Oct 24, 2024
/
Updated:
/
Author:
Download

Contents

Contents will automatically be generated

[This paper is a modified version of a blog published by the University of Nottingham https://www.nottingham.ac.uk/policyengagementblog/is-political-apathy-threatening-democracy.]

Dr Christopher Pich

Introduction

Voter engagement has been declining across the globe since the beginning of the 1990s and this growing trend has been raising many concerns amongst policymakers, researchers, and elected officials. This paper explores the decline in voting and the impact it has on our democracy and how democratic organisations can re-engage voters.

Summary

The number of people engaging in electoral processes is an indicator of democratic health. The rise in voter disengagement paints a bleak picture for how our democracies are currently functioning.

Voting is a complex and dynamic process involving not only behavioural but also emotional and cognitive factors at different levels of engagement. To add to this, voters often develop their political attitudes, feelings and behaviours through time and individuals can meander from engagement to disengagement.

Understanding voter engagement over time is crucial as it has the potential to identify strategies and solutions to address the barriers to engagement, which include the rise in apathy, cynicism and disillusion with the electoral process.

Jersey has the lowest voter turnout among developed countries. Some of the barriers to voting include:

  • Individuals feeling that their vote was irrelevant,
  • confusion and disconnect with the political system,
  • the impact of politics itself,
  • the perceived calibre of candidate politicians,
  • the unclear nature of the electoral process,
  • the lack of difference between the candidates, politicians and/or political parties.

Outreach programmes designed to raise awareness and understanding of voter engagement and civic responsibility have been practically non-existent as well as being inconsistent across institutions.

There is a need to develop and co-create long-term educational outreach programmes on voter engagement. The programmes should be co-developed with a range of stakeholders including elected officials, industry specialists and importantly voters. The co-developed programmes will result in an island-wide curriculum for institutions in Jersey, which will ensure consistency, strengthen the current provision, and provide greater accessibility and transparency for voters.

The steady decline in voting

The number of people engaging in electoral processes is an indicator of democratic health. The rise in voter disengagement, cynicism and a widening disconnection between voters and electoral participation across the board paints a bleak picture for how our democracies are currently functioning. If voter disengagement continues to rise, it poses a direct threat to the integrity of elections and electoral democracy, the stability of governance of states as well as empowering disruptive narratives that speak to people who feel underrepresented.

Voting is a complex and dynamic process involving not only behavioural but also emotional and cognitive factors at different levels of engagement. To add to this, voters often develop their political attitudes, feelings and behaviours through time and reflect across their journey. Existing research suggests that individuals can meander from engagement to disengagement from political event to political event so it is crucial that we continue to monitor this dynamic and ever-changing journey as it could highlight ways that we can strengthen voter engagement and subsequently our democracy.

Initiatives to try to re-engage disengaged voters can be counterproductive if currently engaged voters become disengaged in the future so it is important for policymakers to focus on currently engaged voters as well as disengaged ones. Therefore, studying voter engagement over time is crucial for researchers and practitioners to identify potential solutions and interventions to barriers to disengagement, which include the rise in apathy, cynicism and disillusion with the voting process. Studying voter engagement, disengagement and re-engagement is more important than ever but continues to be an under-developed and under-represented area of study which is where our Jersey Project comes in.

How can we sustain voter engagement? Lessons for policymakers and researchers

According to Ledgerwood and Lally (2024), the number of people engaging in the electoral process is an indicator of democratic health. However, voter disengagement, cynicism and widening disconnection between voters and electoral participation is on the rise and this trend is not restricted to one jurisdiction. In fact, voter engagement has been declining across the globe since the beginning of the 1990s and this growing trend raises many concerns among policymakers, researchers, and elected officials. For instance, if voter disengagement continues to rise, it poses direct threats to the integrity of electoral democracy, the stability and governance of states and empowers disruptive ‘voices, ideologies, and messages’.

Therefore, research examining voter engagement, disengagement and re-engagement remains a priority issue and an under-developed and under-researched area of study. Nevertheless, the voter journey is a complex, dynamic and multifaceted process and deserves ongoing attention and routine investigation. For example, researchers have acknowledged that voter engagement involves not only behavioural but also emotional and cognitive dimensions and different levels of engagement.

In addition, voters often develop their political attitudes, feelings and behaviour through time and embark on a reflective journey often transitioning from different levels of engagement across political events, which in turn can impact engagement at future political events. Existing research suggests the voter journey is subject to change and individuals can meander between engagement-disengagement from political event to political event. It is crucial to continue to monitor this dynamic ever-changing journey as this could highlight mechanisms to strengthen electoral democracy.

Furthermore, policy makers, strategists and researchers should not prioritise disengaged voters and forget to continue to reach out to engaged voters. Otherwise, the strategies and initiatives introduced to appeal to disengaged voters may be counterproductive, particularly if engaged voters become disengaged in the future, which would have an adverse impact on voter turnout in future elections.

Therefore, understanding voter engagement over time is crucial for researchers and practitioners as it has the potential to identify strategies and solutions to address the barriers to engagement, which include the rise in apathy, cynicism and disillusion with the electoral process and maintain engagement. With this in mind, I believe further research is needed to investigate how voters engage with political events, identify barriers to engagement and explore their (dis)engagement with the political process.

The Jersey project

In my recent research with Jersey, we have identified barriers to engagement as well as uncovering opportunities for re-engagement. Jersey experienced the lowest voter turnout among members of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) and continued a low trend of engagement with growing disconnection in national elections. Turnout in the 2022 general election was 41.6%, down from 42.3% in 2018 so we explored some of the reasons for this. Some of the barriers included:

  • Individuals feeling that their vote was irrelevant,
  • confusion and disconnect with the political system,
  • the impact of politics itself,
  • the perceived calibre of candidate politicians,
  • the unclear nature of the electoral process,
  • the lack of difference between the candidates, politicians and/or political parties

During the research, we found that outreach programmes designed to raise awareness and understanding of voter engagement and civic responsibility were practically non-existent as well as being disconnected and inconsistent across institutions (i.e., schools, colleges and other educational establishments) in Jersey. Furthermore, we heard from voters, educational specialists and elected officials a need to develop and co-create long-term educational outreach programmes on voter engagement. For example, it was argued “it all starts with education”. Programmes need to be developed for five specific groups in Jersey:

1. young voters

2. newly qualified voters

3. returning islanders

4. apathetic voters

5. engaged voters

The programmes should be co-developed with a range of stakeholders including elected officials, industry specialists, and importantly voters. The co-developed programmes will result in an island-wide curriculum for institutions in Jersey, which will ensure consistency, strengthen the current provision, and provide greater accessibility and transparency for voters. Once developed, the targeted voter engagement programmes will be led by a series of “Voter Engagement Champions”.

This project will serve as a pilot study which can be upscaled and applied to different political systems including in national and international contexts. So watch this space as we continue to develop the pilot and see what results it brings for the people of Jersey.

*************************

Dr Christopher Pich is Associate Professor in Marketing, Nottingham Business School.

References

Henn, M., Weinstein, M., & Forrest, S. (2005). Uninterested youth? Young people’s attitudes towards party politics in Britain. Political Studies, 53(3), 556–578. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9248.2005.00544.

Kostelka, F., Krejcova, E., Sauger, N. and Wuttke, A., (2023). Election frequency and voter turnout. Comparative Political Studies, 56(14), pp.2231-2268.

Ledgerwood, E. and Lally, C. (2024). Election turnout: Why do some people not vote? UK Parliament Research, Rapid Response, Published Wednesday 24th April 2024, DOI: https://doi.org/10.58248/RR11.

Olaniran, B. and Williams, I., (2020). Social media effects: Hijacking democracy and civility in civic engagement. Platforms, Protests, and the Challenge of Networked Democracy, pp.77-94.

Pich, C. (2023). Exploring the Voter Journey in the Context of Jersey: Engagement, Barriers and Recommendations, in Privileges and Procedures Parliamentary Select Committee Report, States of Jersey Parliament.

Pich, C., Harvey, J., Armannsdottir, G., Poorrezaei, M., Branco-Illodo, I., & Kincaid, A. (2018). Marketing Brexit: An exploratory study of young voter engagement in relation to the EU referendum. International Journal of Market Research, 60(6), 589–610. https://doi.org/10.1177/1470785318793260

Pickard, S. (2019). Politics, protest and young people: Political participation and dissent in 21st Century Britain. Palgrave Macmillan UK.

Poorrezaei, M., Pich, C., Armannsdottir, G., Branco-Illodo, I. and Harvey, J., (2023). Exploring young voter engagement and journey mapping across political events. International Journal of Market Research, 65(5), pp.532-565.

Russell, A., Fieldhouse, E., Purdam, K., & Kalra, V. (2002). Voter engagement and young people” Research Report. The Electoral Commission. 1-904363-03-2.

Sloam, J. and Henn, M., (2019). Youthquake 2017: The rise of young cosmopolitans in Britain (p. 129). Springer Nature.

Solijonov, A. (2016). Voter Turnout Trends around the World, Supporting Democracy Worldwide, Published 31st December 2016, Accessed at https://www.idea.int/publications/catalogue/voter-turnout-trends-around-world.

‍

Related pages
Knowledge Centre:
40 people who have shaped the Island
Jersey in Brief
Jersey's Economy
Jersey's Constitution
Jersey's Heritage
Jersey's History
Jersey's Legal System
Jersey's National Anthem
Jersey's Natural Environment
Jersey's Parishes
Jersey's Political System
Jersey's Population
Jersey's Public Finances
Jersey's Public Services
Policy Briefs:
2026 General Election
Ageing population
Alcohol  licensing
Arts and Heritage
Carbon Neutral Roadmap
Dogs
Economic policy
Economic trends
Education
Energy policy
Entertainment licensing
Environment and Planning
External Relations
Financial Services
Government Plan
Healthcare
Home Affairs
Hospital
Housing
International Development
Population policy
Re-instating senators
Regulation of taxis
Sport
Top issues for islanders
Transport policy
University level education in Jersey
Wind farm
Research:
Election turnout in Jersey
Housing and social mobility in Jersey
Improving the consultation process
Jersey's secondary education system
Low income in Jersey
Problem Gambling in Jersey
Social mobility in Jersey
University education on-Island
Think Pieces:
Improving education outcomes in Jersey - Rachael Williams
Is political apathy threatening democracy? - Christopher Pich
Let's invent a Channel Islands way - Kevin Keen
New approaches needed for taxis and tourism - James Lewis
On-Island higher education - Dr Michael Goldstein
Principles for tax policy - Mark Boleat
Restoring trust in Jersey politics - Mark Boleat
Vision CI - realising the potential - Chris Brock

Subscribe to our Newsletter...

Subscribe
info@policy.je
follow us
Knowledge CentrePolicy BriefsResearchAcademic CentreThink Pieces
HomeAbout UsUseful Links NewsContact
© 2024 Policy Centre Jersey | Registered Charity No. 467
Made in Jersey by WedigitalPrivacy NoticeCookies Settings
By clicking “Accept”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information.
ManageDenyAccept
Privacy Preference Center
When you visit websites, they may store or retrieve data in your browser. This storage is often necessary for the basic functionality of the website. The storage may be used for marketing, analytics, and personalization of the site, such as storing your preferences. Privacy is important to us, so you have the option of disabling certain types of storage that may not be necessary for the basic functioning of the website. Blocking categories may impact your experience on the website.
Reject all cookiesAllow all cookies
Manage Consent Preferences by Category
Essential
Always Active
These items are required to enable basic website functionality.
Marketing
These items are used to deliver advertising that is more relevant to you and your interests. They may also be used to limit the number of times you see an advertisement and measure the effectiveness of advertising campaigns. Advertising networks usually place them with the website operator’s permission.
Personalization
These items allow the website to remember choices you make (such as your user name, language, or the region you are in) and provide enhanced, more personal features. For example, a website may provide you with local weather reports or traffic news by storing data about your current location.
Analytics
These items help the website operator understand how its website performs, how visitors interact with the site, and whether there may be technical issues. This storage type usually doesn’t collect information that identifies a visitor.
Confirm and close